Comment on Solberg and Jensenius: The temporal dynamics of embodied pleasure in music

Maria Witek, Peter Vuust

Abstract

In the paper ‘Pleasurable and Intersubjective Embodied Experiences of Electronic Dance Music’, Ragnhild Torvanger Solberg and Alexander Refsum Jensenius report on a study in which the movements and self-reported affective responses of a group of dancing participants were recorded and related to structural properties of Electronic Dance Music. They observed that, compared with tracks that had a relatively flat dynamic development, tracks which included a ‘break-down’, ‘build-up’ and ‘drop’ of textural layers were associated with greater changes in movement amount and higher ratings of pleasure. Here I comment on their results and methodological approach and use the opportunity to address the continuous pleasure that was treated as a control in this experiment, discussing some reasons why affective responses to music with more evenly distributed dynamic progressions are so often ignored.